How to Be a Good Panelist: Why One Clear Idea Beats Five Smart Answers

November 21, 2026 · Antonio Neves

How to Be a Good Panelist: Why One Clear Idea Beats Five Smart Answers

How to Be a Good Panelist: Why One Clear Idea Beats Five Smart Answers

Most panels blur together an hour later. The panelist people remember walked in knowing what they actually think.

November 21, 2026

"I can't believe they only paid us $500."

A woman on a panel with me said that, or something pretty close to it, back when I was still working in TV in New York City and just starting to get invited to sit on panels. Say what? I was shook, because I didn't get paid anything.

The other folks on that stage knew what they brought to the panel was worth something. I didn't know that yet. Today, after 400+ keynotes, I think about panels mad different, and the money is only part of it. The bigger part is what you walk in with.

The short answer: A good panelist walks in knowing what they actually think about the topic, answers each question directly, tells a short story when it proves the point, and builds on the other panelists instead of repeating them. Audiences tend to forget the panelists who were smart and agreeable, and they remember the one who said something they hadn't heard before, said it plainly and stuck with it.

What makes a good panelist?

A good panelist adds something nobody else on the stage is adding. That's most of the job.

Presentation coach Joel Schwartzberg put it well in Toastmasters magazine's November 2026 issue: "Audiences will remember the panelists who helped them think differently." He also wrote that "Panels should feel like conversations, not a series of mini speeches."

Most panels don't feel like that. They feel like four smart people politely agreeing with each other for 45 minutes. Everybody's nice, everybody's qualified, and an hour later nobody in the room can tell you who said what.

Do audiences actually like panel discussions?

Yes, when they're done well. When Talent Bureau surveyed 250 professionals who'd been to a work event in the past year, 40% picked panel discussions as a preferred format, just behind interactive workshops at 44% and ahead of keynote talks at 31%. It's a speakers bureau's own survey, so treat it as a signal, not the final word.

"Done well" is doing a lot of work there. The Experience Design Report 2026 from Encore and Boldpush surveyed 447 event professionals and found panels scored highest for satisfaction at events of more than 10,000 people, but only when they were well organized. And in PCMA's Convene, event strategist Liz Lathan called the typical panel about the most useless session at a conference. Planners know the bad version too. They've sat through plenty of them.

Why do most panelists blend together?

Because they prepare to talk about the topic, and the topic is the same for everybody up there. If the panel is called "The Future of the Workforce," all four of you walk in ready to talk about the future of the workforce. Odds are you'll say four versions of the same thing.

For example, picture the director of an apprenticeship program sitting on a panel about the skilled labor shortage. This is a hypothetical. The safe answer is "We need to get more young people into the trades." True. Every head in the room nods, and nobody remembers it by lunch.

The answer only she can give sounds more like this: "Most apprentices don't quit because the work is hard. They quit because nobody ever told them what they'd be making in year three." Now the moderator has somewhere to go, the panelist next to her has something to push on, and the room has something to bring up at the coffee break.

In my keynote work I call the generic stuff leaves and the earned truths roots. I break that down in How to Write a Keynote Speech, so I won't repeat it here. A panel is just the place where leaves show up fastest, because there are four of them sitting side by side.

Everybody on that panel is gonna be smart, and odds are the one people quote in the hallway after is the one who walked in knowing what they actually think.

Antonio Neves

How do you prepare for a panel discussion?

Get clear on what you think before you worry about what you'll say. Schwartzberg's advice is to prepare points instead of a script, with a few core ideas and a few short stories ready a week or more ahead, and to do your homework on the event, the audience and the moderator. That's good, public advice and I'd follow it.

The part most people skip comes before the points. It's knowing what you actually believe about this topic, the thing you'd still say if the other three panelists disagreed with you. Without that, your prep turns into a handful of things anybody in your field could say, and you're back to blending in.

That's also the hardest part to do alone. You've been doing your work so long that your best take on it doesn't sound like a take to you. It just sounds like a regular Tuesday.

What separates a forgettable panelist from a memorable one?

Mostly small choices, made over and over for 45 minutes. A lot of these line up with Schwartzberg's advice.

Notice that the right column isn't about being louder. The panelist people remember often talks less than everybody else, and when they do talk, they actually say something.

Should you speak on a panel for free?

Sometimes, and it helps to know which time it is. Plenty of panels pay nothing and are still worth it for who's in the room. But my $500 panel taught me there's usually a budget somewhere, and somebody on that stage may be getting paid. I go through when free pays off and when it doesn't in Speaking for Free.

Can a panel lead to paid speaking?

Yes, when people leave knowing what you stand for. A panel puts you in front of a room that might include somebody who books speakers. The catch is that a panel splits attention four or five ways, so the only way anybody remembers you is if you said one thing clearly enough to repeat.

"Who was the one who said the thing about year three?" That question, asked at the coffee break, is how a panel turns into an invite. It's one of the channels I rank in How to Get Speaking Engagements.

And if you've got that one idea, odds are you've got the start of a talk. What makes you a good panelist is the same thing a planner needs before they'll book you for a keynote.

Walk onto your next panel knowing what you think

Every quarter I take on a few keynote coaching clients. Unfortunately, I can't sit down 1:1 with everybody, so I built Build Your Keynote, a speaking accelerator built on my process and the way I coach. It's eight sections, asked one at a time. You answer in your own words, and when an answer is thin, it pushes on the specific thing you said the way I would in a 1:1 instead of moving you along. Every word starts as something you said. You walk away with your core insights, a program description and a three act outline, so the next time somebody hands you a mic on a panel, you already know your take.

To be clear, it's not a course and there are no videos. If you want talking points for Thursday's panel, it's not for you. It only works if you answer honestly, especially on the questions where your first answer sounds like everybody else's. The first section is free, no card.

Since everyone has an incredible experience to share with the world, they are just a few short steps away from building a powerful keynote. And when they discover emotional arcs and the clear, defined moments of their lives, this can turn into an extraordinary presentation about something they would otherwise believe is not worth sharing. All stories are palpable if we know how to communicate them.

Mark Holden, Chicago, Wealth Management Advisor

FAQ

How long should a panelist's answer be?

Usually a minute or two. Lead with the answer in your first sentence so the moderator can follow up, and leave room for the other panelists.

What should I say when the moderator introduces me?

Keep it short and tied to the event's theme. One or two parts of your story that explain why you're on this stage beat your full resume.

How do you disagree with another panelist?

Acknowledge their point, then share yours as what you've seen in your own work. Kind, honest disagreement is often the best moment of a panel.

Do panelists get paid?

Some do and many don't. It depends on the event and its budget. Free can still be worth it when the room is the right one.

Is a panel easier than giving a keynote speech?

It's less time on your own, but it's harder to stand out. You're sharing the stage with smart people, so a clear point of view matters even more.

Antonio Neves has delivered 400+ keynotes for organizations including Google, Amazon, Visa and McDonald's. He's a former journalist with NBC, PBS and Nickelodeon, a Columbia Journalism School graduate, and the creator of Build Your Keynote.